Archive for December, 2010

Blood & Urine Testing in Ohio; O.A.C. 3701-53-03

December 31st, 2010
Blood samples, right: freshly drawn; left: tre...
Image via Wikipedia

Ohio Administrative Code 3701-53-03 regulates the testing of blood, urine and other bodily substances for purposes of evidential testing.  Section (A) is specific to alcohol and approves gas chromatography and enzyme assays as approved testing techniques.  “The technique or method must have documented sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, precision and linearity. The technique or method can be based on procedures which have been published in a peer reviewed or juried scientific journal or thoroughly documented by the laboratory.

O.A.C. 3701-53-03(B) sets forth the approved methods for testing blood, urine and bodily substances for controlled substances or metabolites of controlled substances.  Statutory definitions for controlled substances and metabolites of controlled substances are set forth at Ohio Revised Code section 3719.011. Section (B) also incorporates the permit requirements set forth at O.A.C. 3701-53-07 and O.A.C. 3701-53-09.  The approved scientific techniques are:

  1. Immunoassay;
  2. Thin-layer chromatography;
  3. Gas chromatography;
  4. Mass spectroscopy;
  5. High performance liquid chromatography; or
  6. Spectroscopy.

O.A.C. 3701-53-03 is set forth in its entirety below:

3701-53-03 Blood, urine and other bodily substance tests.

(A) Alcohol in blood, urine and other bodily substances shall be analyzed based on approved techniques or methods. The technique or method must have documented sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, precision and linearity. The technique or method can be based on procedures which have been published in a peer reviewed or juried scientific journal or thoroughly documented by the laboratory. Approved techniques or methods include:

(1) Gas chromatography; and

(2) Enzyme assays.

(B) Controlled substances or metabolites of a controlled substance as defined in section 4511.19, and drugs of abuse as defined in section 3719.011 of the Revised Code in blood, urine, and other bodily substances shall be analyzed using techniques or methods approved by the director of health as part of the permit process as specified in rules 3701-53-07 and 3701-53-09 of the Administrative Code. The approved analytical techniques or methods are:

(1) Immunoassay;

(2) Thin-layer chromatography;

(3) Gas chromatography;

(4) Mass spectroscopy;

(5) High performance liquid chromatography; or

(6) Spectroscopy.

All positive results of tests specified in paragraph (B) of this rule must be confirmed by one or more dissimilar analytical techniques or methods and must be part of a testing procedure. The analytical techniques or methods used for confirmation must have similar or improved sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, precision and linearity. The approved techniques or methods can be based on procedures which have been published in a peer reviewed or juried scientific journal or thoroughly documented by the laboratory.

Dayton DUI attorney Charles M. Rowland II has successfully challenged blood tests in Ohio and stands ready to offer you an aggressive defense.  If you have been charged with DUI (now called OVI) in the Miami Valley or throughout Ohio, CONTACT Dayton OVI lawyer Charles M. Rowland II today at (937) 318-1DUI or 1-888-ROWLAND.

Enhanced by Zemanta

Dayton Bankruptcy Attorney Zachary Bushatz

December 29th, 2010

Are you going to be starting off 2011 with leftover Christmas bills?  Do you wonder how you are going to afford to pay off your Christmas debt in this lousy economy?  You are not alone; the average consumer doesn’t finish paying off their holiday credit card bills until May and consumer counseling agencies see a 25 percent increase in the number of people seeking help in January and February.   But it doesn’t have to be that way for you.  The law office of Dayton bankruptcy attorney Zach Bushatz can help eliminate the holiday hangover of your credit card bills and give you a fresh start for the New Year.  We help consumers reduce or eliminate their debts and obtain a new outlook and fresh financial start.

We are not a credit consolidation company that promises great rewards by locking you into a payment you eventually cannot afford to make.  Instead, we work with you to reduce or completely eliminate your debt.

So if you want to get a fresh financial start to kick off 2011 or if you are drowning in too much debt, give the Bankruptcy Law Office of Zach Bushatz a call at 937-879-9542 and see how he can eliminate your debt and get you on your way to a freedom from oppressive bills.

Enhanced by Zemanta

Happy Holidays from Dayton DUI

December 25th, 2010
A Christmas market in Clifton Mill, Ohio, Unit...
Image via Wikipedia

Happy holidays to Ohio’s fine Prosecuting Attorneys.  Every day they fight for justice and use the enormous power that they are given in a prudent and judicious manner.  Happy holidays to Ohio’s judges, who are the very embodiment of our evolving and ever-changing system of laws, norms and morals.  Most of all, happy holidays to Ohio’s law enforcement community.  They put their lives on the line so that all of us can enjoy our freedoms.  One cannot imagine the chaos and suffering that would be wrought were it not for these fine men and women.  As we open our gifts on Christmas morning, there is an officer somewhere doing an impossibly dangerous job and doing it with dignity and a respect for the perpetrator that will never be reciprocated.  I did not want to let this season pass without offering this sincere and oft-overlooked sentiment… Thank you.

-Charles M. Rowland II-

Enhanced by Zemanta

Arrested for OVI in Ohio? How You Act is Important

December 23rd, 2010

Your behavior with law enforcement can be vital to the officer’s decision making. Investigating officers are given a great deal of discretion in handling any situation. They may simply be seeking information to put in their report or they may be deciding whether or not to issue a citation. At the initial stage you must know your rights in order to protect yourself and, if necessary, aid your attorney in presenting your case to a jury. At this point it is vital to remember anything you say or do will be used against you. Arguing with the officer, complaining or bad-mouthing the officer does not help you and may give the officer an excuse to arrest you. Given the increased utilization of in-car cameras, the jury may also be allowed to observe your behavior and demeanor at the scene. Stay calm and in control of your emotions and treat the officer the way you would wish to be treated. Above all – KNOW YOUR RIGHTS!

When a police officer pulls behind you he or she is observing your driving. The following is a list of symptoms in descending order of probability that the person observed is driving while intoxicated. The list is based upon research conducted by the National Highway Traffic Administration:

1. Turning with a wide radius
2. Straddling center of lane marker
3. “Appearing to be drunk”
4. Almost striking object or vehicle
5. Weaving
6. Driving on other than designated highway
7. Swerving
8. Speed more than 10 mph below limit
9. Stopping without cause in traffic lane
10. Following too closely
11. Drifting
12. Tires on center or lane marker
13. Braking erratically
14. Driving into opposing or crossing traffic
15. Signaling inconsistent with driving actions
16. Slow response to traffic signals
17. Stopping inappropriately (other than in lane)
18. Turning abruptly or illegally
19. Accelerating or decelerating rapidly
20. Headlights off

Speeding is not usually a symptom of impaired driving because it requires the use of quicker judgment and reflexes, thereby making it more reflective of sobriety. Take particular note of when you notice the officer behind you and any landmarks that you see. How long you were followed may be an issue that will be raised at trial. Obviously, it is important to obey the speed limit and observe all traffic laws. If you suspect that the officer is looking for a reason to pull you over, don’t give him one. Most importantly, do not panic and run from the officer. It is not a crime to leave a bar at night but it is a crime to flee and/or elude the officer. By obeying all traffic laws you are not giving the officer a reason to pull you over and you may not be stopped. If you are stopped, do not assume that the officer already has his or her mind made up. Take note of the exact location of the stop as your attorney may be able to challenge certain aspects of the case based on the physical environment of the stop. Again, stay calm and in control.

When the officer arrives at your car window he/she is understandably concerned about safety. Keep your hands where the officer can see them, do not run and do not touch the officer. The officer usually begins the stop by asking if you know why he pulled you over, and may ask if you’ve had anything to drink. You are not required to answer potentially incriminating questions. A polite “I would like to speak with an attorney before I answer any questions” is a good reply. On the other hand, saying that you had one or two beers is not incriminating: it is not sufficient to cause intoxication — and it may explain the odor of alcohol on the breath.

Interfering with or obstructing an officer is a crime and you can be arrested for it. You must present the officer with your driver’s license and identification upon request. Upon being stopped under suspicion of drunk driving, the officer will try to stick his head near your face and attempt to have a conversation with you. He is seeking to ascertain if you have an odor of alcohol about your breath or person. The officer is also seeking to determine if your speech is slurred. By getting a good look at your face, the officer can determine if your eyes are blood-shot or glassy. Not surprisingly, finding an odor of alcoholic beverage, slurred speech and glassy eyes will prompt the officer to ask you to step outside the vehicle to take some field sobriety tests. You have every right to refuse the standardized field sobriety tests! These tests are being conducted so as to be used against you in court. Common field sobriety tests include the HGN, a test of your eyes, the Walk and Turn test and the One Leg Stand test.

If the officer asks you to exit the vehicle you have a choice. If you do not wish to exit, you are forcing the officers hand. He or she may arrest you and take you to the station. If you do exit, the officer may ask you to take the field sobriety tests sited above. If you do not take the tests then law enforcement has less evidence against you. If you feel you are impaired a trip to the station will be less intrusive than a conviction. Refusing to cooperate with the field sobriety tests will not result in an automatic license suspension, but refusing to take a blood, breath, or urine test at the station most certainly will. By knowing that you have a right to refuse field sobriety tests, you may be able to limit the evidence against you at trial.

Once outside the vehicle, an officer has the right to pat you down for his own safety. Do not resist this search but make it clear to the officer that you are not consenting to any further search. It is not a crime to refuse to answer questions, but doing so will arouse police suspicion. Remember, if an officer is questioning you he or she is seeking evidence to use against you. Do not make any incriminating statements. A common tactic used by some experienced officers is the “it’s all over now, I’ve arrested you, let’s be honest” approach. They are seeking to solicit information to bolster the arrest and use against you in court. If you feel you are being treated unreasonably, or that your rights are being violated, the scene is not the proper place to argue the point. You can discuss the officer’s behavior with an attorney or file a complaint with the Internal Affairs Department later. A common technique that an officer will use will be to ask you “how many beers have you had?” The best answer is simply to refuse to answer the question and ask the officer if there is anything else that you can help him/her with. Again, by knowing your rights you will gain a measure of control over this intimidating situation.

Contact Charles Rowland by phone at 937-318-1DUI (937-318-1384), 937-879-9542, or toll-free at 1-888-ROWLAND (1-888-769-5263).

For after-hours help contact our 24/7 DUI HOTLINE at 937-776-2671.

Visit www.DaytonDUI.com, www.SpringfieldDUI.com, www.OhioDUIdefense.com, www.KetteringDUI.com, www.BeavercreekDUI.com, www.FairbornDUI.com,  www.VandaliaDUI.com, www.HuberHeightsDUI.comwww.MiamisburgDUI.com, www.XeniaDUI.com or www.CharlesRowland.com.  Immediate help is available by filling out the CONTACT form on any of these pages.

For information about Dayton DUI sent directly to your mobile device, text DaytonDUI (one word) to 50500.  Follow DaytonDUI on Twitter at www.Twitter.com/DaytonDUI or Get Twitter updates via SMS by texting follow DaytonDUI to 40404. DaytonDUI is also available on Facebook and you can access updates by becoming a fan of Dayton DUI/OVI Defense.

You can also email Charles Rowland at: CharlesRowland@CharlesRowland.com or write to us at 2190 Gateway Dr., Fairborn, Ohio 45324.

Enhanced by Zemanta

DUI Crime Lab Requirements, O.A.C. 3701-53-06

December 22nd, 2010
Holy Rosary Hospital Laboratory, two technicia...

Image via Wikipedia

O.A.C. 3701-53-06 sets forth the lab requirements for proper testing in DUI cases

Ohio Administrative Code 3701-53-06 (formerly O.A.C. 3701-53-05) contains the requirements for laboratories who administer alcohol and drugs tests.  Section (A) sets forth the rules that labs must keep chain of custody records and test results for three (3) years.  All positive blood, urine and other bodily substances shall be retained for a period of not less than one year.  Section (B) requires lab proficiency.  Section (C) requires that,”[t]extbooks and package inserts or operator manuals from the manufacturer may be used to supplement, but may not be used in lieu of the laboratory’s own procedure manual for testing specimens.”

The experienced DUI attorney will file a detailed discovery request asking for documentation that each of the requirements of the administrative code are being complied with.  It is also smart to send a letter to the prosecutor advising that you will challenge not only the chain of custody aspects of the case, but that you will also challenge the collection procedures.  A visit to the lab or a visit with your expert to the lab may also be in order.  Questioning the lab technicians may reveal some very advantageous facts for your client.

DUI counsel should also file a motion to preserve the defendant’s blood or urine specimen for later analysis or independent testing.  In State v. Bruce, 2008-Ohio-5514, a 2nd Appellate District case, the attorney properly filed a motion to preserve and the court issued an order.  However, the attorney did not serve the order preserving the evidence on the laboratory.  The lab destroyed the evidence.  The 2nd District Court of Appeals held that the defendant’s due process rights were not violated as the lab had not acted in bad faith and that it was the defendant’s responsibility for failing to provide timely notice to the lab.  The lesson: ATTORNEY BEWARE!

Ohio Administrative Code 3701-53-06

(A) Chain of custody and the test results for evidential alcohol and drugs of abuse shall be identified and retained for not less than three years, after which time the documents may be discarded unless otherwise directed in writing from a court. All positive blood, urine and other bodily substances shall be retained in accordance with rule 3701-53-05 of the Administrative Code for a period of not less than one year, after which time the specimens may be discarded unless otherwise directed in writing from a court.

(B) The laboratory shall successfully complete a national proficiency testing program using the applicable technique or method for which the laboratory personnel seek a permit under rule 3701-53-09 of the Administrative Code.

(C) The laboratory shall have a written procedure manual of all analytical techniques or methods used for testing of alcohol or drugs of abuse in bodily substances. Textbooks and package inserts or operator manuals from the manufacturer may be used to supplement, but may not be used in lieu of the laboratory’s own procedure manual for testing specimens.

(D) The designated laboratory director shall review, sign, and date the procedure manual as certifying that the manual is in compliance with this rule. The designated laboratory director shall ensure that:

  1. Any changes in a procedure be approved, signed, and dated by the designated laboratory director;
  2. The date the procedure was first used and the date the procedure was revised or discontinued is recorded;
  3. A procedure shall be retained for not less than three years after the procedure was revised or discontinued, or in accordance with a written order issued by any court to the laboratory to save a specimen that was analyzed under that procedure;
  4. Laboratory personnel are adequately trained and experienced to perform testing of blood, urine and other bodily substances for alcohol and drugs of abuse and shall ensure, maintain and document the competency of laboratory personnel. The designated laboratory director shall also monitor the work performance and verify the skills of laboratory personnel;
  5. The procedure manual includes the criteria the laboratory shall use in developing standards, controls, and calibrations for the technique or method involved; and
  6. A complete and timely procedure manual is available and followed by laboratory personnel.

(E) Any time the designated laboratory director is replaced, another permitted laboratory director or applicant shall be designated and approved by the director.

Enhanced by Zemanta